giovedì 29 novembre 2007



How to judge online sources???

Hi guys!!!
Luckily this week in our e-tivity we won’t learn how to use a new tool but we will have time to restore our poor minds and reflect on and discuss what criteria we use to evacuate the “almost limitless amount of information” we have come across on the Internet during our previous e-tivities. Usually when I need to research something; I prefer to use Internet because it’s easier and it “will give you absolutely everything”. But, on the other hand, I perfectly know that when you decide to work on Internet you must be aware that you have to make more efforts that with a simple research in the library.

First of all you have to select and “filter” information you really need from others that are simply “rubbish”. Then you have to pay attention to the authenticity of the materials and check if what you find out inside the blogsphere is true or not. So, at the beginning, the fir step you have to do is “the judgement of online sources” and after that you can take them as the main material for your works. I liked too much reading a definition, which I found in Internet, which compared the “evaluation sources” as a kind of DETECTIVE WORK!!!
What about me, I haven’t any strategies to filter information from the Net, but I tend to be more critical as possible in my readings. Most depends on what kind of information one is looking for. If I’m looking for facts, historical events or news reports, I think that some sites or sources need not to be checked because they are so popular and well-known that anyone could trust them – I’m referring to sites as the BBC or the CNN networks or the site of “Il Corriere della Sera”. I think that no one could doubt the validity of the materials that these sources presents (I mean, I’m speaking about the validity of the site and not whether the content is right or not; that’s another crucial point!).

On the other hand, if I’m looking for personal opinions about a specific topic, further researches or studies about an issue or simply out of curiosity, I tent to check the author and the publisher. The way in which information is presented is important as well; it should be accompanied with a list of further explanations or with an updated bibliography on that topic.

Anyway, in my opinion, the most important thing when someone search something online is to have a lot of patience and to read the more s possible about that particular topic; in this way one has the possibility to compare different opinions, noticing points in common or in contrast, so finally one can chose properly.

5 commenti:

Alberto ha detto...

Hi Alessandra!
I agree with you; the Internet is an incredible tool to find everything, but we've to pay attention to what it offers...
I don't have a specific strategy in looking for sources, too; I simply try to understand what kind of material I'm dealing with...
Finding what we need is not simple, but fortunately some websites as those you cited (BBC, CNN...)make this "jungle" a bit easier...

Claudia ha detto...

Hi Alessandra!

I was reading your post and... when you say
'...what criteria we use to evacuate the “almost limitless amount of information” '
you probably mean evaluate! It make more sense to me (in Italian evacuare informazioni would be really funny, in English it is just a matter of moving instead of judging). ;-)

Anyway, I agree with almost everything you said, the only thing I'd like to point out is that when you find information on what you consider reliable sites (BBC, Corriere della sera, CNN...) you should pay attention to the authorship , and to what kind of information you're reading too. Talking about newspapers for instance you have to be aware of the difference between facts and opinion (both available in an article).
As you said it is a long work that must be done with great care!

See you on Monday!
Ah, while typing you made some little mistakes (missing letters..) go and see when you have time!

Claudia

Claudia Trivellato ha detto...

Hi Alessandra!
I'm perfectly agree with you: not only I think that the Internet is the esiest means to find information,too, but also that it can create some problems concerning authorship ect.
I seach both online and in libraries as you.

Serena Santi ha detto...

Hi!
I agree with Claudia. Even in 'reliable' sources like Il Corriere della Sera there is a differense between objetive facts and subjective opinions. As we well know in Italy there are a lot of newspapers which have left or right political opinions. I think it's very important to understant what view point someone is following. As Alberto would say we have to be aware of the other side of the coin.

Laura Zock ha detto...

Hi Alessandra!
I agree with your reflections and I think you are right: on the Net the amount of information is so huge and out of control that we all should to be critical about its use for our researches!
Did you have a look at the websites of those Universities suggested by Sarah? The advice they give when surfing the web and collecting sources is clear and useful!

See you later!
Laura